Mistborn: The Final Empire Review

I first discovered fantasy author Brandon Sanderson when I read The Gathering Storm, book 12 of the famous The Wheel of Time series, which Sanderson had been asked to finish after the death of Robert Jordan, the series’ creator. I was hugely impressed by Sanderson’s work on that book – so much so that I immediately went out in search of his other novels, and found this, Mistborn: The Final Empire, the first book of his epic fantasy Mistborn trilogy.

Fans of epic fantasy will all be familiar with the over-used trope of a protagonist who begins the story as a young farmer, discovers he/she has hidden magical powers, and then embarks on an epic quest to defeat a “Dark Lord” *cough* Lord of the Rings, Star Wars, The Wheel of Time, The Sword of Truth; practically 90% of all fantasy books *end cough*. A modern fantasy author has to break away from this overused – and now horribly clichéd – story arch if they want to write something original and interesting. Sanderson succeeds in this brilliantly, basing his trilogy on a creative new premise: imagine the Dark Lord won.

The world of Mistborn is dark and mysterious. The plant-life of the world is almost entirely extinct; the sun now burns red; the world is covered in a choking blanket of ash, which rains down almost continuously; and at night-time mysterious mists rise up to cover the entire land. The Lord Ruler presides over it all, ruthlessly controlling his subjects through violence, fear and oppression. It is the world of the Final Empire, and he has reigned unchallenged for over one thousand years.

The story of this book centres on two main characters, Vin, a young thief, and Kelsier, a charismatic criminal mastermind, as they come up with a daring plot to overthrow the Lord Ruler’s tyranny. They plan to do this by forming an elite covert team to steal the Lord Ruler’s hoard of atium, an incredibly valuable metal which is the foundation of his economic control, while at the same time facilitating a rebellion of the oppressed skaa population. Mistborn is a superb mix of traditional fantasy and Ocean’s 11 style storytelling, and the heist-based plot is a great way of reinvigorating a somewhat staid genre.

Mistborn’s magic system, Allomancy, is very unique and engaging. Allomancy is based on “burning” metals to give the user super-human powers. There are 8 basic metals that an Allomancer can use: pewter, for example, greatly enhances the user’s physical capabilities; brass lets the user manipulate the emotions of others; tin greatly enhances the user’s senses. The most interesting two metals are iron and steel, which let the user “Pull” and “Push” metal respectively. One application of this is pushing and pulling coins, which effectively turns them into reusable bullets. Weight, however, plays a huge role in how this Allomancy works: if you “pushed” a lamppost, for example, you would be thrown through the air instead. Mistborn–allomancers who can burn all the metals–can use this technique to travel at incredible speeds through the city, half-flying half-jumping. Allomancy is a really well thought out magic system which has great depth and intricacy, while at the same time lending itself to fantastic fast-paced action sequences.

There are plenty of interesting themes explored here as well. The theme of class division is very prominent throughout: “skaa” workers comprise the majority of the population and they are horrifically abused and oppressed, being treated as less than human by the wealthy noblemen. Trust is a big theme in Vin’s story, as she moves from a world of petty thievery and gang violence to one of friendship and interdependence.

The plot of the book is excellently written; it’s fast-paced and interesting, and it packs in a lot of really shocking twists and turns. It’s a world you want to learn about and Sanderson does a wonderful carrot-and-stick job, tantalising you with one more revealed secret and ten new questions in every single chapter. Sanderson is an expert in deception, and pulls off some ingeniously dramatic twists several times during the story. Be prepared to be amazed.

Mistborn’s biggest weakness, however, is characterisation. Most of the characters are extremely one dimensional. Kelsier, Vin, Sazed and Elend are the only characters with any real depth to them, and even these are not portrayed as fully as they could be. Sanderson admits that he squeezed a plot that would usually take several books into this single novel, and while this has its benefits it also comes at the cost of putting plot before characters. Conversations are often there just for the sake of plot explanation and inner dialogue and reflection is minimal.

This results in a story that isn’t as emotive as it could have been. The Lord Ruler doesn’t inspire as much fear or hatred as the plot implies he should; Kelsier, not as much awe; the skaa’s plight, not as much righteous outrage. The plot spends too much time telling and not enough showing. It’s not totally skewed – the balance just isn’t 100% right.

Even taking these flaws into account, Mistborn is still one of the most interesting new fantasy trilogies of recent years. The action makes it a fun and accessible read and it’s an original and compelling story. Sanderson weaves a plot with more devilish twists than most murder mysteries. A lot of fantasy books retread the same old themes so it’s refreshing to see an author trying something new. Highly recommended.

4 Stars

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Mistborn: The Final Empire Review

  1. Good review. I quite agree – it was a rather interesting engagement with the fantasy genre, though it did have the flaws. Personally, I would have liked to get more insight into a number of the other characters – but it just isn’t there. And, I must warn, while he does make some effort with a few of them in the sequels, that particular trend does continue. And my one little needling point on the plot is that it seemed…well, frankly all together easier to spark this grand rebellion than one might expect…particularly as beaten down as the Skaa are constantly portrayed.

    I think this was the strongest book of the three – but then, I do suppose that is fairly typical of a lot of trilogies.

  2. I’ve read book 2 (in the process of writing a review!) and I actually thought it was better than book one. The characterization is much better in it, though you’re right to point out that secondary characters are still very neglected. I feel that in book 2 he succeeds in bringing the characters to a more acceptable level of detail overall, though it’s still not one of his writing’s strengths. Apparently some people were complaining about this issue cropping up in Tower’s of Midnight as well (Wheel of Time book 13, which I haven’t yet read). Hopefully Sanderson will work on this aspect in his next few novels because if he gets it right he could easily become one the fantasy’s best authors.

    You’re definitely right about the plot stretching the limits of what’s believable as well. Kelsier’s charisma is, I think, supposed to provide the reason for everything working in the end – but the weakness in establishing that charisma as a reality for the reader unfortunately translates into a plot whose resolution seems a little bit too neat and convenient. It still works pretty well though once you’re willing to suspend your disbelief that little bit more 🙂

  3. I think what really made this book series speak to me was the use of metals as the magic system. It seems that he put a lot of time and thought into the finer points of this power. Even going as far as to explain the dangers of using poisonous metals. He is a great author and just seems to get better as he moves forward. I really appreciate you review and must agree about the lack of character development. Although, I think he does a much better job at that with his new series that I mention in your review of book 2. He’s still no George R.R. Martin with character development, although it can get daunting to keep up with so many characters at once.

    J.R.

    • Yeah, Allomancy really is a great magic system. I still think The Wheel of Time has the best magic system out of everything I’ve read so far, but Allomancy is definitely up there. And who DOES beat G. R.R. Martin’s character development anyway?! 😀 I’m looking forward to reading more of Sanderson, he’s one of the most interesting new fantasy authors out there. And by all accounts he’s getting better with each book!

  4. Pingback: Mistborn: The Hero of Ages, Review | From the Mind of Kevin

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s